Blog

Compostable vs Biodegradable Bags: What’s the Difference?

Compostable vs Biodegradable Bags: Key Differences Explained

In a world increasingly leaning towards sustainable living, terms like “compostable” and “biodegradable” are often used interchangeably. However, they mean different things and serve distinct purposes in our journey toward eco-friendliness. Understanding these differences is vital to making informed choices for reducing waste and protecting the planet.

What Are Compostable Bags?

Compostable bags are made from natural materials such as cornstarch, vegetable oils, or other organic matter. They are designed to break down in the composting environment into nutrient-rich compost used to enrich the soil. The decomposition process takes place within a period of a couple of months upon disposal in the appropriate location, for instance, in industrial composting facilities or home compost bins.

These compostable bags have the standard requirements to meet; examples include ASTM D6400 in the United States and EN 13432 in Europe, where they have to break down within a certain period without giving out bad residues. For this reason, they are very useful for food waste, garden clippings, or any other organic material.

What Are Biodegradable Bags?

Biodegradable bags are made from materials that can break down naturally into smaller components such as water, carbon dioxide, and biomass. However, the time scale may be quite long, from a few months to several years, depending on environmental conditions such as temperature, moisture, and exposure to microorganisms.

Unlike biodegradable bags, compostable bags do not necessarily leave behind nutrient-rich compost. They break down into natural components without necessarily adding any value to the soil. Some biodegradable bags contain synthetic additives to facilitate faster decomposition. This means that if the bag is not completely made from natural materials, there is a likelihood of leaving behind microplastics.

Differences Between Compostable and Biodegradable Bags

Although both types of bags are considered an eco-friendly substitute for traditional plastic, they differ in some fundamental ways:

  • Material Composition: Compostable bags are exclusively made from organic, natural products, whereas biodegradable bags can be prepared from a blend of natural and synthetic materials.
  • Decomposition Process: Compostable bags need specific conditions for composting and decompose into nutrient-enriched compost. Biodegradable bags break down more slowly and can leave the soil unenriched.
  • Environmental Impact: Compostable bags do not leave any toxic residue behind and enhance soil health. Biodegradable bags will leave traces of microplastics behind if they are not entirely natural in origin.
  • Standards and Certification: Compostable bags have stringent certification standards, whereas biodegradable bags do not have to be certified always.

Benefits of Compostable Bags

  • Eco-Friendly: Compostable bags are renewable sources, thereby reducing dependence on fossil fuel sources.
  • Soil Enrichment: They break into organic matter, adding fertility to the soil.
  • Waste Diversion: Suitable for food and yard waste, reducing the burden on landfills.
  • Non-Toxic Decomposition: No toxic chemicals are emitted during decomposition.
  • Certified Guarantee: They adhere to high standards to guarantee that they meet environmental standards.

Benefits of Biodegradable Bags

  • Versatility: Suitable for a wider range of waste types than organic matter.
  • Ease of Use: Can decompose in various environments, including landfills.
  • Cost-Effective: Often cheaper than compostable alternatives.
  • Partial Eco-Solution: Better than traditional plastic for reducing long-term waste.
  • Widespread Availability: Available in many more stores and applications than compostable ones.

When to Use Compostable Bags vs Biodegradable Bags?

The choice between compostable and biodegradable bags depends on the specific use case. Compostable bags are ideal for food waste, gardening, and situations where the bag will end up in a composting facility. Biodegradable bags are better suited for general waste disposal or areas lacking access to composting facilities.

If your goal is to actively contribute to soil health and close the loop on organic waste, compostable bags are the clear choice. For broader waste management needs where composting isn’t feasible, biodegradable bags offer a convenient and more sustainable option compared to traditional plastics.

Conclusion

Compostable and biodegradable bags are very useful tools in the fight against plastic pollution. Understanding their differences and applications can help you make choices that are aligned with your values and the needs of the environment. Both provide significant advantages over conventional plastics, but effectiveness depends on proper usage and disposal.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Is 100% biodegradable the same as compostable?

No, 100% biodegradable means the material will break down naturally over time, but it doesn’t guarantee that the process will result in nutrient-rich compost or occur within a specific timeframe. Compostable materials, however, decompose under controlled conditions and enrich the soil.

Do compostable bags really decompose?

Yes, the compostable bags decompose entirely in composting environments, generally within 90-180 days. They need such conditions as heat, moisture, and microbial activity for effective breakdown.

Can I place biodegradable bags in compost?

Not always. Some biodegradable bags could contain synthetic additives that may contaminate the compost. Always check whether the bag is labeled as “compostable” and meets the standards of composting.

Can compostable bags be used in regular trash?

While they can go in the everyday trash, compostable bags are really meant for the compost pile. They won’t break down into the intended rich soil in the landfill because those conditions aren’t present.

Can biodegradable bags be composted at home?

Some types of biodegradable bags could work in your home compost system, but certainly not all of them. Compostable bags are your best bet in a home composting situation.

How to determine authentic eco-friendly bags?

Check the packaging for the presence of such certifications as ASTM D6400, EN 13432, or similar standards. In addition, check what materials are used and choose a product from a reputable brand that clearly states their eco-friendly status.